shinyjenni: Steph eating popcorn and wearing 3D glasses (does it have a bat on it?)
[personal profile] shinyjenni
I finished season two of Supergirl! What a mixed bag this season was.

The bad:

  • MON-EL. Ugh, just everything about him was pretty much terrible. Events in the season finale notwithstanding, he's pretty much the poster boy for Privileged White Men Get What They Want. He had a few nice fish out of water moments at the beginning (though even those veered a little bit towards "men can't be expected to be competent so women have a duty to look after them", and was beginning to evolve into a not entirely awful person by the end, but by that point it was too little, too late. I'd already seen him be given so much for so little, including so much screentime, that I just did not care about him even a little bit.

  • Kara/Mon-El. I'll freely admit my biases here; I am, as I have mentioned ad nauseam, so bored of m/f relationships in media that they have to work really hard to win me over, and this one did the opposite of that. It was full of awful tropes (Kara forgiving Mon-El's betrayal because he ~*~loves~*~ her in the musical episode was a particular low point), it ate up Kara's storylines, and the actors had basically no romantic chemistry. (This was only highlighted by how much chemistry Mon-El and Winn had in their first few episodes; I'd've been slightly more here for Mon-El as Winn's boyfriend rather than Kara's.)

  • Very related to the above points: sidelining James and breaking up him and Kara. There was basically no reason for this other than racism, and it was awful and I hated it. Kara telling Cat in the season finale that she'd never felt about anyone the way she felt about Mon-El was a particularly sour note. (I also slightly resent the fact that I had to sit through all that love triangle nonsense last year for nothing.) I did like some of James's stuff this year (see below), but overall he was so completely sidelined both in terms of screen time and narrative, and it was terrible. (I do feel like the show realised towards the end of the season that they'd been floundering with his character and tried to retroactively make it into an arc about him not knowing what he wants to do, but it wasn't enough.)

  • I really liked M'Gann but I felt like she didn't get nearly enough development. And I certainly wasn't here for her relationship with J'onn being romantic; I don't know how old the characters are supposed to be but it definitely felt like a significant age gap. (Getting her together with Kara would have fixed two problems with this season in one fell swoop, I'm just saying.)

  • Kara's journalism storyline didn't really work, mostly because the show didn't really commit to it and just brought it up when it was plot relevant. Also Snapper Carr felt like a character written by someone who'd watched the previous season but hadn't understood what made Cat work.

  • I miss Lucy.


The good:

  • Maggie/Alex. <3 I loved everything about this storyline (ok, I'm not sure about the proposal, but everything else was so great I'm willing to give it the benefit of the doubt). Alex's gradual coming out was handled so carefully and so beautifully; it made me cry at several episodes in a row. I really enjoy both characters and their relationship, especially the way they talk through their problems like grown ups. Their scenes have been the highlight of every episode they've been in. I also really liked how everyone's reactions to their relationship were on the hopeful end of realistic.

  • Kara! I haven't been a fan of some of her storylines this year, but she herself is still wonderful: kind, sweet, optimistic, powerful, headstrong. I love her.

  • I was a little worried about Superman appearing but I think the show handled it really well. He's a really great Superman, but he's also very clearly a secondary character in Kara's story. I liked how well he got on with everyone, that was very Supergirl. (Winn's epic crush on him continues delightful.) And now the conversation around the show can move on from "when will SUPERMAN show up??????"

  • Winn's had a pretty good year - he veered into comic relief territory a little bit, but never in a way that undermined him or made him the butt of the jokes, so I enjoyed it. I like how he's being portrayed as such a fundamentally good natured character. And I also enjoyed that the show allowed him to be scared without condemning him for it (particularly the way Alex reacted). Plus his superpowered alien girlfriend was GREAT and I hope we see more of her next year.

  • The team ups and growing friendship between Winn and James were so nice, not least because it meant James actually got some screen time occasionally. The little moments of the two of them hanging out with Kara, Alex and sometimes Maggie were also great - they really felt like a genuine friendship group.

  • HI CAT. I missed her when she was gone but what little she did have was pretty great. I like how she has this fundamental faith in other women, unless she's got a good reason not to. I also ship her with President Wonder Woman QUITE A LOT. Also... "go get 'em, Supergirl". SHE KNOWS <3333 (So of course she also made Guardian the second she saw him. <3 I loved James's look of dismay through the tiny eye slit - Mehcad Brooks has done so much with so little this season, what a good he is.)

  • As detailed above I have NOT been happy with James's storylines (or lack of them) this season, but I did enjoy J'onn getting to mentor him a little in that one episode.

  • I love that President Wonder Woman's actual name contains a tribute to Olive Byrne as well as William Moulton Marston; I wish they'd fitted Elizabeth Holloway Marston in there too.


So overall, I'm cautiously optimistic for season three? I feel like second seasons can often be a bit rocky, and this one also had to accommodate network and casting changes too, so I'm hoping it improves on some of the above next year now that that's all settled down a bit.

(no subject)

Date: 2017-06-01 10:29 am (UTC)
st_aurafina: Supergirl from behind, looking over her shoulder (Supergirl: looking over shoulder)
From: [personal profile] st_aurafina
SO MUCH LOVE for Alex and Maggie - I got very teary too, it was strange to see a functional lesbian relationship develop all by itself, and not be torn to shreds by ~dramaz. And not end up with dead characters. One day that won't be strange, but right now it really is. Strange but delightful.

I was really surprised at how much I liked the Superman episodes - he turned out to be a family member and someone who knew Supergirl in a different way to what we've seen and that was actually quite lovely.

I did not expect to like Winn *ever* but he's turned into the best kind of goofy, brave sidekick guy. He's so great with James, he's so great with his alien girlfriend, he's so great with his incredible, ridiculous crushes.

I wish Mon-El could have stayed in the position of quippy alien bartender and (okay, mostly in my head) Kara's best gay, because he fits that niche really well and is heaps of fun. He is terrible for her as a romantic partner because he gets in Lena's way wasn't written very well.

So, yeah, I agree! Season 3 looks very positive from here - they've survived the sophomore curse and shifting to another network, and the show is in a good place right now. /cautiously optimistic.

(no subject)

Date: 2017-06-01 11:02 am (UTC)
purplefringe: Amelie (Default)
From: [personal profile] purplefringe
I agree with LITERALLY EVERY SINGLE WORD you have written here. A+ reviewing. Laura and I watched the last 2 eps last night, and both yelled a LOT when Kara said that thing about never having felt about anyone the way she feels about Mon-El. UGH, WHY, SHOW??? (Also, we did laugh a lot during that last ep - from the opening shot of Morgana, I mean, Lena, asleep on the bed which I've DEFINITELY seen in a bunch of Merlin vids, to the 'PEOPLE OF EARTH, YOUR ATTENTION PLEASE', Vogon-esque opening speech from Evil Mom #2, it seemed quite cobbled together from lots of other ridiculous SFF shows. But I did enjoy lots of individual moments, such as every time Kara had a face, and everything Cat Grant chooses to be)

But despite all the Mon-El stupidness, I have enjoyed this season! I hope that next season we don't get a replacement Mon-El or more Snapper Carr...dudes in this show should be strictly limited to J'onn, James, Winn-as-hilarious-sidekick, and then guest appearances from Superman and The Flash, who turn up a few times a season to make heart-eyes at Kara, buy her ice cream, duet with her, tell her how great she is, then go away again.

Final question: how many babies in pods did Kypton launch?!?! No wonder Kara was knocked off course. As Laura said, there was probably not much in the way of air traffic control going on.

(no subject)

Date: 2017-06-02 05:10 am (UTC)
rahirah: (Default)
From: [personal profile] rahirah
Mon-El is just SO boring and annoying. I kept hoping that in the last couple of episodes he'd realize that he has a responsibility to his people to go home and rebuild the planet and reform the government, and that takes precedence over playing kissyface with Kara. Alas no.

Profile

shinyjenni: Wonder Woman deflects bullets with her bracelets (Default)
incorrigibly frivolous

June 2017

S M T W T F S
    1 23
45678910
111213141516 17
18192021222324
252627282930 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags